Where Passion Meets Pizza

At Prohibition Pizza, we’re more than just a pizza place – we’re a family-driven dream brought to life in the heart of High Springs. Owners Kelly and David Potter combined their passion for cooking with a commitment to quality, crafting authentic New York-style pizzas with handmade dough and fresh, natural ingredients. From our unique artisan pizzas to oven-baked wings, salads, and desserts, we’re dedicated to serving delicious food in a welcoming, community-focused atmosphere. Located across from High Springs Brewing Company, we’re proud to be voted Best Pizza in Florida 2024 and Best Lunch 2024!

A Nod to Days Gone By

Every Pizza on our menu is a nod to the periods iconic flavors and spirit. We source the finest ingredients, reminiscent to the dedication to quality found in secret distilleries of the past. Our dough is handmade and fermented 72 hours in advanced. Sauces are hand milled and toppings are sliced fresh daily to create pizzas that are both familiar and extraordinary. Each bite promises a taste of luxury and rebellion that defined the 1920’s, when creativity flourished despite restrictions.

Award Winning Excellence

Your Virtual Visit to Prohibition Pizza

Why Prohibition Pizza?

The Buzz Around Town - Google Reviews

  • Best pizza ever, I also love the pretzel and beer cheese they have. The Limoncello Mascarpone Cake is Devine.

    Seyanilas Avatar Seyanilas
    January 6, 2025

    Cool place, great pizza!

    Larry Rice Avatar Larry Rice
    October 13, 2024

    The underground pizza is to die for. The theme of the place ties in perfectly for a great atmosphere. We visited on a home-buying trip from Maryland. I grew up in the Northeast in and around the Philadelphia area, and this was by far the best pizza I’ve ever had. This place is Florida’s hidden gem!

    media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1
    Brandon Venini Avatar Brandon Venini
    November 13, 2024
  • Great pizza

    Shawn Williams Avatar Shawn Williams
    October 13, 2024

    Great pizza the meatball appetizer and the pretzel and beer cheese appetizer were great there was 4 of us everyone loved it have already been back for a couple pizzas to go since the original visit πŸ˜‹

    Herman Saylor Avatar Herman Saylor
    October 13, 2024

    Very cute place to go for some good pizza! Love the roaring 20’s vibes and playlist.

    media thumbnail 0
    Laina Avatar Laina
    October 13, 2024
  • Fantastic food, possibly the best pizza I've ever had

    Randall Purdy Avatar Randall Purdy
    December 13, 2024

    Great pizza.

    J P Avatar J P
    November 13, 2024

    Awesome customer service, plenty of outdoor seating, and the pizza was great! My boyfriend (who is from NY and also one of the toughest pizza critics I’ve met) and I both loved the Buffalo Chicken Pizza and the Meat Lovers. The pizza was light and perfectly baked, not greasy at all like most typical pizza joints! We are from out of town, but will be making the drive back in the future πŸ©·πŸ™ŒπŸΌ

    media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1
    Makenzie McBride Avatar Makenzie McBride
    October 13, 2024
  • Always the best gluten free pizza & cheesy bread!

    Harry McBride Avatar Harry McBride
    November 13, 2024

    Amazing food, service, and atmosphere! Easily one of the best!!!

    Mr. 11Bravo Avatar Mr. 11Bravo
    November 13, 2024

    Staff were extremely helpful and willing to customize the order. We are definitely going to be returning!

    Jacob Thompson Avatar Jacob Thompson
    December 30, 2024
  • I was passing through High Springs and encountered this awesome place! Voted 2024 Florida best pizza.

    media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1
    william romero Avatar william romero
    October 13, 2024

    Great customer service pizza a great atmosphere fit perfect!!

    Nidster Avatar Nidster
    December 13, 2024

    Food on point with great fresh toppings.

    Charles Teggart Avatar Charles Teggart
    December 13, 2024
  • Very good gluten free pizza/cheesy garlic bread

    Paul Muller Avatar Paul Muller
    October 13, 2024

    Toppings are fresh, generous, and delicious. And the crust is actually the best I've ever had. Our #1 pizza joint .

    Sandra Fobb Avatar Sandra Fobb
    November 13, 2024

    Very friendly. Accepts cash and walk-in orders. Great menu. Nice vibe while still feeling casual and comfortable.

    Sal Ruth Fox-Moritz Avatar Sal Ruth Fox-Moritz
    December 13, 2024
  • First visit and hope to be back soon

    Shalene Terrell Avatar Shalene Terrell
    December 13, 2024

    This place is hands down THE BEST pizza you can get. If you're in town it's a must try. Highly recommend getting creative with the build your own option. Tasty quality ingredients and friendly staff that always greets you with a warm smile. PS it re-heats better than any other pizza I've ever had too!

    Keni Alvarez Avatar Keni Alvarez
    December 13, 2024

    Limited inside seats. Great Pizza.

    Debra Sellers Avatar Debra Sellers
    December 13, 2024
  • Nice find and worth the trip from Gainesville. We had a lunch meeting and client was really in mood for pizza. They have many options and everyone enjoyed their pizza. Great service

    Rickie Estevez Avatar Rickie Estevez
    December 13, 2024

    Off the beaten path: if you're looking for a fun weekend venture, head to High Springs and while you're there stop in at Prohibition Pizza. One block west of the downtown 4 way stop and next to the old train depot. Kitchen is modern and works like a fine tuned watch . Staff greet you immediately and if your dinning in the food comes fast. Looks like they have all kinds of Pizza and salads as well as a few other specialty dishes. Young families and others all with a smile. They have seating outdoors and a few tables inside. Definitely worth the trip. Vegetarian options: Lots of salads depending on your level of commitment Wheelchair accessibility: Easily accessible from the street parking.

    media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1media thumbnail 2media thumbnail 3media thumbnail 4media thumbnail 5media thumbnail 6media thumbnail 7
    Texxwash 352 (TexxWash) Avatar Texxwash 352 (TexxWash)
    December 13, 2024

    The quality of the dough is unmatched, as well as the sauce and toppings. The staff is very charming and the scenery is very pleasing comforting. I like the recent skeleton out front. Parking: Right infront there’s a good amount but south the block is some more space.

    Brown Sugar Gaming Avatar Brown Sugar Gaming
    November 13, 2024
  • We have ordered take out pizza several times and it's always great food. Tonight we decided to sit down and eat there. The wings were phenomenal and we tried the Dillinger pizza which was absolutely amazing! Everyone was pleasant, dining area/ kitchen was clean and overall a 10 out of 10 experience. If you haven't tried Prohibition Pizza in High Springs, you definitely need to!!

    Cory Dube Avatar Cory Dube
    December 16, 2024

    Great Pizza!!!

    Anthony Castronovo Avatar Anthony Castronovo
    October 13, 2024

    Worth the short drive from I-75!!! YOU WILL LOVE THIS PIZZA! EAT HERE! Mrs. Potter the owner is an absolutely delightful hostess and chef extraordinaire! The gluten-free, dairy-free garlic "cheeze" breadsticks were phenomenal as an appetizer. Gluten- free pizza crust with vegan mozzarella was beyond delicious....most divine GLUTEN-FREE DAIRY-FREE pizza we have ever eaten (LOL and we have eaten lot of pizza!) There is something about the way the pizza crust was prepared that was to die for! Ingredients are fresh, real and without additives! Great care was taken to ensure no cross-contamination including exclusive pans, utensils, etc. Congratulations on your best pizza in Florida award for 2024!!! it is extremely well-deserved! Good luck at the next competition and we will see you again as soon as we can! Adorable character in the dining area and also had an adorable patio. Thank you for treating is so kindly and for the amazing food...finding gluten-free vegan food that is this delicious was a highlight of our trip! Dietary restrictions: outstanding gluten-free crust made from dough and not a pre-fab/frozen crust. Dairy-free (vegan) mozza was the perfect addition to this amaaaaazzzing pizza πŸ• πŸ˜‹! Parking: There is parking directly beside the restaurant and also plenty of parking on the street and surrounding streets. free!

    media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1
    Lisa O'Blenis Avatar Lisa O'Blenis
    October 13, 2024
  • λͺ¨λ“  메뉴가 ν›Œλ₯­ν–ˆκ³  λ„μš°κΉŒμ§€ λ‹€ λ§›μžˆμŠ΅λ‹ˆλ‹€. 심지어 식어도 λ§›μžˆμ–΄μš” ! μΉœμ ˆν•˜μ‹œκ³  λΆ„μœ„κΈ°λ„ μ’‹κ³  μ•žμ— λΈŒλ£¨μ–΄λ¦¬λ„ μžˆμ–΄μ„œ μ£Όλ³€ μŠ€ν”„λ§μŠ€ κ°€μ…¨λ‹€κ°€ κ°€κΈ° 쒋은 μ‹λ‹Ήμž…λ‹ˆλ‹€.

    media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1media thumbnail 2
    Dae-Uk Shin Avatar Dae-Uk Shin
    October 13, 2024

    Cheese pizza & garlic parmesano chicken wings. Yum!!!

    Yvette Doherty Avatar Yvette Doherty
    December 13, 2024

    These guys have a great combination of quality and quantity of food ..using all fresh ingredients. I’ve gotten 4 pizzas in the last 5 weeks..Not going back to PP as long as Prohibition is in business. Voted the BEST pizza in Florida..for a real good reason.

    Rand Taylor Avatar Rand Taylor
    December 13, 2024